Breaking News
More () »

Babysitter charged with murder in 11-month-old Indiana girl's death

The man who had been watching Mercedes Lain, 37-year-old Justin Lee Miller, has been charged with murder.
Credit: Plymouth Police Department
Mercedes Lain, 11 months old, (left) and Justin Lee Miller, 37, (right).

PLYMOUTH, Indiana — A man who was watching an 11-month-old northern Indiana girl before she was found dead has been charged with murder. 

Police say Mercedes Lain, of Plymouth, Indiana, was found dead in a remote, wooded area in Starke County. The man who had been watching Mercedes, 37-year-old Justin Lee Miller, is being charged with murder in a case that was opened against him in Starke County. 

RELATED: 11-month-old Indiana girl found dead; suspect and parents charged

Miller was originally charged in Marshall County with neglect of a dependent resulting in death. He could face 20 to 40 years in prison if convicted. 

Credit: Plymouth Police Department
Mercedes Lain, 11 months old.

Marshall County Prosecutor Nelson Chipman announced last week her death had been ruled a homicide citing evidence that Mercedes died from blunt force injuries to the head. 

RELATED: Death of 11-month-old Indiana girl ruled homicide; babysitter and parents charged

Miller was located the morning of Aug. 16. After being questioned multiple times, police said he helped lead them to Mercedes' body on Aug. 18.

Mercedes' mother and father, Tiffany Coburn and Kenneth Lain, are also being held on a charge of neglect of a dependent for the circumstances of letting Miller watch their baby.

Credit: Marshall County Sheriff's Office
Kenneth Lain and Tiffany Coburn

In a court document, Kenneth Lain and Tiffany Coburn said they left their daughter Mercedes with a family relative, Justin Miller, on Aug. 13. The parents had claimed they left the baby with Miller for a few days so they could have a break.

They called police on Aug. 15 to report Mercedes missing. According to court documents, they told police Miller said he left Mercedes with a neighbor since Lain and Coburn were not home.

When officers tried to follow up with Lain and Coburn about the timeline of events involving Mercedes, they said they were unable to make contact until Aug. 16 at 8:30 a.m. Police said that Coburn said she was coming in to talk to them, and was waiting on a ride from her sister. 

Police said Coburn never showed up and when they talked to her sister, she told them she had not seen Coburn since 3 a.m. when "she dropped them off from looking for the baby."

RELATED: Mercedes Lain: 5 things to know about her case

In court documents, both Coburn and Lain were noted as being "uncooperative in looking for their child."

Coburn was ultimately found outside of the Economy Inn the afternoon of Aug. 16. Lain was located at the Red Rock Inn in Plymouth around 6 p.m. on Aug. 16.

According to court documents, Miller gave conflicting information over several days on his whereabouts during the days Mercedes was missing. He had even claimed at one point that he had dropped the baby off with a neighbor.

On Aug. 18, police interviewed Miller again at the Marshall County Jail. In court documents, Miller said that on Aug. 14, he was at a home in Mishawaka and when he woke up, Mercedes was dead.

Investigators said Miller then told them he had disposed of the baby's body at a property in Starke County. Later on Aug. 18, court documents allege Miller led officers to Starke County Road 1025 East and County Road 40 North, where Mercedes' body was found.

Miller has an initial hearing set for Aug. 24. Mercedes' parents have pretrial conferences set for September.

A hearing for the murder case against Miller hadn't been scheduled at the time of publishing. 

What other people are reading: 

Before You Leave, Check This Out