Breaking News
More () »

Indianapolis woman charged with reckless homicide in chain-reaction crash has history of at-fault crashes

Prosecutors say Kelli Anderson was involved in another fatal crash killing an Indianapolis ER doctor weeks prior, plus five other at-fault crashes since August 2019.

INDIANAPOLIS — A woman is now facing charges for allegedly causing a crash that killed a 28-year-old mother of four earlier this month. The crash comes just weeks after she was involved in another fatal crash, when she allegedly hit and killed an Indianapolis emergency room doctor as he walked down a north side street. 

The Marion County Prosecutor's Office charged 55-year-old Kelli Anderson with one county of reckless homicide and six counts of criminal recklessness for a June 9 crash near the intersection of East 52nd Street and North Keystone Avenue.

The crash happened just before 5 p.m. Six cars were stopped at a traffic light on Keystone Avenue when Anderson's car crossed the median and hit them. Eight vehicles total were involved in the crash. Kiana Burns, who was third in line at the red light, was the only person injured in the crash. She died two days later.

"Out of eight cars, Kiana was the only injury," Burns' mother, Denise Gatling, told 13News. "It took them two hours to cut her out of the car is what the detective told me."

RELATED: Young mother killed in northeast Indy crash gives gift of life to others

Anderson told police at the scene she was paying attention and tried to avoid hitting the cars. After being transported to the hospital to get checked out, Anderson told an officer she was trying to evade a car that had cut her off, but misjudged and went onto the median.

A witness told an officer she saw Anderson driving around 50 or 60 mph before going up onto the center median and crashing into the cars. According to information pulled from the car's airbag control module, Anderson was going more than 68 mph when she hit the cars. She did not try to brake, according to the probable cause affidavit.

"When drivers fail to meet their responsibilities on the road, it can result in devastating consequences," Marion County Prosecutor Ryan Mears said. "Because of this incident, four young children have lost their mother."

Anderson told an officer she takes medication daily to treat "severe, life-threatening allergies and epilepsy," according to the probable cause affidavit. When the officer asked if Anderson had had any issues with allergies that day, she said, "Honestly, I blacked out, 'cause I don't remember what happened."

RELATED: Woman gravely injured in chain-reaction crash on Indy's northeast side

Another fatal crash just weeks prior

Through their investigation, police discovered Anderson had also been involved in another fatal crash on May 19, just weeks prior to the incident at 52nd and Keystone. 

Police said the May 19 crash happened when, for unknown reasons, her vehicle crossed into the lane going in the opposite direction on West 49th Street near North Meridian Street. 

She drove over a curb and onto the sidewalk then clipped a utility pole before hitting and killing Brian Dillman, an ER doctor who was walking on the sidewalk. 

Her vehicle also slammed into another utility pole before hitting another car and coming to a stop. 

Neighbors in the north side community were stunned by the news of Dillman's death.

"It's a huge loss. He lives in our neighborhood. Our committee members are friends with the family," said neighbor Allison Madden, who's a member of the Meridian Foundation Public Safety Committee. 

Anderson suffered internal injuries in that crash. At that time, she told police she took prescription medication for seizures and may have blacked out.

After the June 9 crash, Anderson told police she was allowed to continue driving despite her side effects because nothing is wrong with her brain and her issues are all related to allergies. Toxicology results from May 19 and June 9 are still pending.

5 other at-fault crashes

In addition to the two fatal crashes, detectives said Anderson had been at fault in five other crashes since August 2019. Each of those crashes injured another driver. They happened on the following dates:

  • Aug. 3, 2019
  • Feb. 20, 2020
  • March 9, 2021
  • Sept. 2, 2021
  • May 2, 2022

Hospital discharge papers from May 20 said Anderson was told she "is at high risk of harm to herself and/or others and that she should not drive for 6 months until cleared by a neurologist." According to court documents, Anderson indicated she understood her discharge instructions.

Anderson's bond was set at $100,000 and she is scheduled to appear in court Tuesday morning, June 21.

Paid Advertisement

Before You Leave, Check This Out