Murder charge filed against Plainfield man in road rage killing

Dustin Passarelli (Photo: IMPD)
Passarelli appears in court
Murder suspect in court

INDIANAPOLIS (WTHR) — The Marion County Prosecutor's Office has officially filed charges against the man accused of killing 32-year-old Mustafa Ayoubi in a road rage incident last week.

Dustin Passarelli, 33, is facing a murder charge for the death of Ayoubi.

Passarelli allegedly shot and killed Ayoubi after following him off Interstate 465 on the northwest side and getting into a verbal altercation. Ayoubi's family called for the killing to be investigated as a hate crime, after witnesses said Passarelli used religious and racial slurs before shooting him.

"While the disturbing allegations underlying the charge in this case remain to be proven at trial, we are obviously unable to charge this alleged act as a hate crime," Marion County Prosecutor Terry Curry said.

"We have said on many occasions, too many occasions in fact, that hate and crimes motivated by hate are real. Some in the legislature wish to push the dialogue into the hypothetical, but those of us who listen to our neighbors understand that this is an unfortunate reality in our state."

-Terry Curry, Marion County prosecutor

Curry said although the killing cannot be tried as a hate crime in Indiana, he will "vigorously prosecute" Passarelli to get justice for Ayoubi, his loved ones and the Indiana Muslim community.

Arsalan Bukhari, Council on American Islamic Relations, said the family has asked the FBI to start a federal investigation into a possible hate crime.

Zahra Ayoubi speaks to the media ahead of an initial hearing for Dustin Passarelli, who is accused of fatally shooting her brother, Mustafa Ayoubi. (Photo: WTHR/Matt McCutcheon)

According to charging documents, Passarelli admitted to following Mustafa off the highway because he believed the victim threw something or hit his car. Passarelli told detectives Mustafa called him a "dirty Jew" during the verbal altercation that followed, and he responded by cursing at him and calling him names, including "something" about Mohammed.

Passarelli then told detectives he started firing through his car window because Mustafa had punched his window, causing it to crack.

Ayoubi's family issued a statement prior to Passarelli's initial hearing Friday morning. Mustafa's sister, Zahra Ayoubi, said her brother was very funny and touched every person he knew.

"Each time we talk about our memories, we see people laughing and that is the type of person who is missing from our lives right now," Zahra said.

Mustafa's funeral was Thursday.

Passarelli is still in custody without bail.

Filed under: