Supreme Court mulls prayer in government questions - 13 WTHR Indianapolis

Supreme Court mulls prayer in government questions

Updated:
  • HeadlinesHeadlinesMore>>

  • Eyewitness News wins 7 AP awards

    Eyewitness News wins 7 AP awards

    Saturday, April 19 2014 11:59 PM EDT2014-04-20 03:59:03 GMT
    WTHR Channel 13 Saturday was honored with seven first place awards from the Indiana Associated Press, including Best Newscast and Best Continuing Coverage.More >>
    WTHR Channel 13 Saturday was honored with seven first place awards from the Indiana Associated Press, including Best Newscast and Best Continuing Coverage.More >>
  • Pacers Fans leave with minutes still left in the game, disappointed by loss

    Pacers Fans leave with minutes still left in the game, disappointed by loss

    Saturday, April 19 2014 11:16 PM EDT2014-04-20 03:16:57 GMT
    All of the Pacers' fans were decked out in their blue and gold Saturday night. By the time the fourth quarter rolled around, though, fans were singing a different tune. Many left early - even some season ticket holders.More >>
    All of the Pacers' fans were decked out in their blue and gold Saturday night. By the time the fourth quarter rolled around, though, fans were singing a different tune. Many left early - even some season ticket holders.More >>
  • Pope seeks to bring faith to "ends of the Earth"

    Pope seeks to bring faith to "ends of the Earth"

    Saturday, April 19 2014 10:35 PM EDT2014-04-20 02:35:31 GMT
    Pope Francis baptized 10 people Saturday and urged them to bring their faith "to the ends of the Earth" as he presided over an Easter Vigil in St. Peter's Basilica.More >>
    Pope Francis baptized 10 people Saturday and urged them to bring their faith "to the ends of the Earth" as he presided over an Easter Vigil in St. Peter's Basilica.More >>
WASHINGTON, DC -

Even before the United States became a nation, the founders puzzled over a dilemma that's still an emotional one today: how much separation should there be, or must there be, between the government and religion? That question was front and center Wednesday at the U.S. Supreme Court in a case involving prayers at town meetings.

"Lord, thank you for gathering us here this evening."

It's the way cities and towns have opened public meetings for hundreds of years, in a country with God on its currency.

Something like a prayer brings the Supreme Court to order: "God save the United States and this honorable court."

But Justice Elena Kagan asked Wednesday, suppose it began with a minister leading a prayer and talking about the sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross. Would that be permissible?

The issue comes to the court from the town of Greece, New York. Two residents, one Jewish, one atheist, sued, saying prayers that open their town board meetings, nearly always Christian, are unconstitutional government endorsement of a single faith: "We ask these things in your Holy name, Amen."

"I don't think you should have to endure religious indoctrination in order to participate in your own town government," said Linda Stephen.

But the town says it has history on its side:

"We have a rich tradition, back to our founding fathers, of opening legislative meetings with a prayer," said John Auberger, town supervisor.

Several of the Supreme Court's liberals today questioned the practice, saying those who attend a town board meeting to ask for something may feel compelled to join a prayer to avoid offending board members.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked, "Wouldn't those people feel coerced?"

But lawyers for the town say both houses of Congress have always started their days with prayers, from paid chaplains, a practice the Supreme Court endorsed 30 years ago.

Justice Stephen Breyer suggested that the court could draw up rules to make local prayers more inclusive, like those in Congress, to all faiths.

But Justice Samuel Alito said, "I just don't see how it is possible to compose anything that you could call a prayer that is acceptable to all these groups."

A majority of the justices seem willing to let government-led prayer continue without drawing up new rules, based on not much more than the fact that it's been done since the nation's founding.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Friends, colleagues remember life of slain IMPD officer

    Friends, colleagues remember life of slain IMPD officer

    Saturday, April 19 2014 12:34 PM EDT2014-04-19 16:34:23 GMT
    Picture provided by familyPicture provided by family
    The influence of an IMPD officer killed by her ex-husband in a murder-suicide went far beyond the police department. Neighbors and those who worked with Ofc. Kimberlee Carmack are still trying to understandMore >>
    The influence of an IMPD officer killed by her ex-husband in a murder-suicide went far beyond the police department.More >>
  • Franklin mom visited by phony CPS workers

    Franklin mom visited by phony CPS workers

    Thursday, April 17 2014 8:11 AM EDT2014-04-17 12:11:37 GMT
    A Franklin woman is warning other mothers after she says two people came to her house and threatened to take her children.More >>
    A Franklin woman is warning other mothers after she says two people came to her house and threatened to take her children.More >>
  • Murder-suicide tragedy rare, but followed pattern

    Murder-suicide tragedy rare, but followed pattern

    Friday, April 18 2014 11:49 PM EDT2014-04-19 03:49:46 GMT
    The domestic violence case that ended in the murder-suicide of two IMPD officers reveals a serious danger for police officers that goes far beyond the risks they face each day in the line of duty.More >>
    The domestic violence case that ended in the murder-suicide of two IMPD officers reveals a serious danger for police officers that goes far beyond the risks they face each day in the line of duty.More >>
Powered by WorldNow