As they near the midway point of the season, they've already doubled their victory total from 2011 and at 4-3 are suddenly talking about the playoff picture.
Nobody expected this.
How have they done it?
Most of the players in this year's rookie class - from Andrew Luck to tight ends Dwayne Allen and Coby Fleener - have become key contributors in the first half of the season.
The latest example came Sunday when unheralded running back Vick Ballard, a fifth-round pick in April, made one of this season's most spectacular plays: a twisting, 4Â½-yard dive that earned perfect marks from the judges and gave Indy a 19-13 overtime victory at Tennessee.