Indiana justice challenged over contentious ruling - 13 WTHR Indianapolis

Indiana justice challenged over contentious ruling

Posted: Updated:
INDIANAPOLIS -

An Indiana Supreme Court justice who wrote a ruling that set off a political uproar faces a rare challenge.

Justice Steven David must pass a retention vote in the Nov. 6 election to keep his place on the state's highest court.

Tea party activists are urging voters to oust him because of a 2011 decision David wrote ruling residents didn't have the right to resist police officers who illegally enter their homes. Critics say the 3-2 decision violated citizens' longstanding right to defend their homes.

Legislators approved a new law this year aimed at negating the ruling.

But the critics are waging an uphill battle. Not a single justice has been removed from the court since 1970.

If David wins, he won't face another retention vote for 10 years.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

Powered by WorldNow