Researchers: Benefits of mammograms often overstated

Researchers: Benefits of mammograms often overstated
Published: .
Updated: .

Each year, thousands of women find themselves in an exam room hoping a few moments of discomfort will help them avoid breast cancer.

But no cancer screening is foolproof and a new review of mammogram studies spanning the past 50 years reaffirms this.

"These studies, when you look at them as a whole, suggest there is a benefit to screening mammography that's probably about equal to a 19 percent reduction in the risk of dying of breast cancer," said Dr. Nancy Keating of the Harvard Medical School.

Researchers say that benefit needs to be weighed against the potential harms. They found that one in five breast cancers spotted during annual screaning may be over diagnosed, meaning that the cancer would never grow or threaten the woman's life.

They also found more than half of women will have at least one false positive.

According to Dr. Keating, "Most of these false positives just require women to come back for additional testing done, additional images and sometimes they require a biopsy."

Doctors also say that new drugs and treatments are the reasons most women are beating cancer today - not mammograms.

"Current breast cancer treatment is so effective that the vast majority of women will survive regardless of how or when their breast cancer is diagnosed," Keating said.

The study found mammograms have a greater benefit for women in their 50s and 60s, but outside experts said this does not mean women in their 40s should skip the test. While more women in this age group need to be screened to save one life, many are willing to bear any potential harm for the chance that the life saved is theirs.

Researchers said mammograms aren't perfect, but it's still the only screening tool we have.

This study was designed to help doctors relay the risks and benefits to their patients and help them come up with an individual treatment plan.